Blog · The 100% cap

A contract bills exactly 100%: why the fourth claim is refused

Across the advance, the claims and the retention release, a contract bills its value exactly, to the fil. What counts toward the 100%, what does not, and where stages, variations and the certified figure fit in.

By , founder of Mizarah, who ran a UAE joinery workshop for 13 years · 7 minute read · Published · Last updated

The problem in one line

A claim that takes a contract past 100% bills money nobody agreed to and VAT nobody owes, so it should be refused, not just flagged in red.

Over-billing is rarely deliberate. Claim 3 gets built from a copy of claim 2's sheet. Someone types 80% when the job is only at 70%. A variation is billed before anyone approved it. A red warning sits at the bottom of the sheet and the claim goes out anyway.

I think a contract should bill its value to the fil, and a claim that would go past it should not be possible to issue at all. It sounds strict, but it saves the awkward call where you explain to a main contractor why the last claim has to be credited back.

What counts toward the 100%

On the reference contract (1,000,000 before VAT, a 30% advance, 10% retention, work billed 30%, 40% and 30%) the 100% is measured on the work certified on each claim, before the advance and the retention come off. 300,000 + 400,000 + 300,000 = 1,000,000, and the contract is done.

The advance tax invoice is not counted again, because it is money received early and taken back out of the claims. The retention release is not counted again either, because it pays out what the claims already certified. A draft does not count until it is issued. A credit note counts, as a minus.

Work certified on the claims1,000,000.00
Claim 4: refused
  1. Claim 1 (30%)300,000.00
  2. Claim 2 (40%)400,000.00
  3. Claim 3 (30%)300,000.00
Net billed on each document, before VAT1,000,000.00
  1. Advance tax invoice300,000.00
  2. Claim 1180,000.00
  3. Claim 2240,000.00
  4. Claim 3180,000.00
  5. Retention release100,000.00
The same 100%, seen two ways. Top: the work certified on the three claims. Bottom: what each document bills net of VAT, deductions before VAT, from the advance to the release.

Look at it document by document and it still adds up. Before VAT, the advance bills 300,000, the claims bill 180,000, 240,000 and 180,000 net, and the release bills 100,000. That is 1,000,000.

The fourth claim, and the 80% that should have been 70%

After claim 3 there is nothing left to bill. A fourth claim of any amount, even one fil, takes the contract over 100%, so it is refused. The same check catches the more common mistake earlier in the job: after claim 1, 700,000 is left, and a claim typed at 80% would take the contract to 1,100,000.

Mizarah claim editor at 80% after 300,000 already billed on a 1,000,000 contract: a red warning says the claim takes the contract over 100% and will be refused, with 700,000 left to bill; the contract panel shows left to bill after it minus 100,000.
The next claim typed at 80% after 300,000.00 already billed: Mizarah warns that it takes the contract over 100% and will be refused, 100,000.00 over. Local test data, invented names.
Mizarah claim editor at 70% after 300,000 already billed: 100% of AED 1,000,000 billed with this claim, AED 0.00 left after it.
At 70% the same claim lands on 100% exactly: 0.00 left to bill after it. Local test data, invented names.

The limit is exact. The last claim lands on 100% and anything above it is over, with no tolerance to hide a few hundred dirhams in. It should be checked when the claim is saved and again when it posts, so two drafts that each fit on their own cannot both reach the books.

One thing the limit must never do is stop a correction. If a contract is already over 100% (an old job, or a variation withdrawn after it was billed), lowering a draft claim has to stay possible. Only an increase is refused.

VAT across the contract: exactly 5%

If the contract bills exactly 1,000,000, the VAT declared across it is exactly 5%: 50,000, each fil once. The documents carry different shares under each method, but the total does not move.

VAT declared across the contract
1,000,000 · 30% advance · 10% retention
DocumentBefore VATAfter VAT
Advance tax invoice15,000.0015,000.00
Claim 19,000.0010,500.00
Claim 212,000.0014,000.00
Claim 39,000.0010,500.00
Retention release5,000.000.00
Total50,000.0050,000.00

The only difference allowed is rounding. VAT is rounded on each tax invoice, so retention released in three parts can bring the total to 50,000.01: a difference of fils, never of dirhams. If the total is off by more than that, look for the advance's VAT declared twice, or a release without its VAT.

Stages: each one bills up to its quantity

The 100% works on the whole contract. Joinery needs the same discipline line by line, because a line is often billed in stages: frames first, then leaves, then fixing.

Take 25 wooden doors at 4,000.00 each, 100,000.00 for the line, split into stages by their share of the price. Every stage covers the same 25 doors.

25 wooden doors, by stage
4,000.00 a door · 100,000.00 for the line
StageShare of the priceWorth for 25 doors
Frame15%15,000.00
Door leaf35%35,000.00
Architrave10%10,000.00
Fixing20%20,000.00
Ironmongery15%15,000.00
Final touch-up5%5,000.00
The line100%100,000.00

Claim 1 bills all 25 frames: 25 × 4,000.00 × 15% = 15,000.00. If claim 2 bills 25 frames again, that is 50 frames on a line of 25 doors. The claim total might still be under 100% of the contract, which is exactly why the stage needs its own limit. Mizarah refuses that save and names the stage: Frame (would bill 50 of 25).

A line billed without stages is held to its agreed value instead, with a small allowance for rounding on the last bill.

Mizarah invoice lines on a phone: Fitted wardrobes and kitchen, Supply of frame, 30% of the line billed, 15,000; and Supply of shutter, 30% of the line billed.
Each claim line names its contract line and the stage it bills, here "Supply of frame". Local test data, invented names.

Variations move the 100%

A contract rarely stays the size it was signed at. The client adds a reception desk, the contract grows from 1,000,000 to 1,150,000, and every claim from then on is measured against the larger figure. An omission is a variation too, and it makes the contract smaller.

A contract with one approved variation
LineAmount
Contract as signed1,000,000.00
Approved variation: reception desk150,000.00
Contract sum now1,150,000.00
Work billed on claims 1 to 31,000,000.00
Left to bill150,000.00

Only an approved variation counts. One that is still being argued about does not move the limit, and one that is rejected or withdrawn stops counting. That keeps the 100% honest in both directions: you cannot bill a variation nobody agreed, and a legitimate final claim against an approved one is not flagged as over-billing.

Claimed is not certified

You claim 200,000. The client's QS walks the site and certifies 180,000. You are paid on 180,000. The other 20,000 is carried to the next claim or argued about.

Keep both numbers. If you edit the claim down to 180,000 and throw the 200,000 away, the next conversation with the client starts without the figure it is about. And put only the certified figure in your books as revenue. Posting the full claim overstates what you are owed by every amount the QS cut.

When I was chasing payments on WhatsApp, the gap between claimed and certified was behind a lot of the slow ones. Our invoice said one figure, their certificate said another, and "which bill?" usually meant "which number?" A claim that matches the certificate tends to get paid without a long thread.

Our own 28-second Short: a contractor chases 18,900 over WhatsApp, then sends a clean claim (30,000 less the advance and retention, plus VAT) as one link. The app screens are real, with test data. Watch it on YouTube.
HOW MIZARAH HANDLES ITTRUE OF THE PRODUCT TODAY

How Mizarah handles it.

In Mizarah a progress claim is raised against its contract. The contract is the quotation's value before VAT plus approved variations, and the limit counts the work certified on every issued claim, plus anything billed before Mizarah. A claim that would take the contract past 100% is refused, exact to the fil, when it is saved and again when it posts. A line billed in stages refuses a stage billed past its quantity.

A claim's first figure is kept as what was claimed. When the client certifies, you record the certified amount (it cannot be more than the claim, and a nil certificate is allowed), bring the claim to that figure, and only then does it post. A posted claim cannot be re-certified; changing it needs a credit note. An ordinary invoice that is not a claim against a contract posts as it always has.

QUESTIONS5 ANSWERS

Common questions.

Does the advance count toward the 100%?
Not a second time. It is money received early and taken back out of the claims, so the 100% is reached by the work certified on the claims.
What if a variation is approved after the contract is fully billed?
The contract sum grows by the variation, so a claim that bills it fits. An approved omission does the opposite and lowers the sum.
Can the VAT across a contract be 50,000.01 instead of 50,000?
Yes, by rounding fils only. VAT is rounded on each tax invoice, so a retention released in parts can add a fil. Anything larger is a mistake.
Why can a claim not post before it is certified?
Because only the agreed figure belongs in your books. The claimed amount is kept on record, and the claim posts once it matches what the client certified.
Is the limit checked per line as well as per contract?
For lines billed in stages, yes: each stage can be billed only up to its quantity. A line without stages is held to its agreed value.

Official sources

Read next on this site

Practical guidance, not tax advice. The figures are worked examples, not anyone’s real contract. Check how the rules apply to your own contracts with your tax agent.

TRY IT ON YOUR OWN CONTRACT14 DAYS FREE · NO CARD

Put one of your own claims through it.

Start the free 14-day trial at mizarah.com and bill a contract you already know the answer to. Or work one bill out first with the free progress bill calculator, either VAT method, no sign-up.