Blog · Retention

Retention VAT: when you charge it depends on how you took it

Retention comes back months or years after the work. Whether its release invoice carries VAT was decided on the claims, long before, and getting it wrong means the VAT is declared twice or not at all.

By , founder of Mizarah, who ran a UAE joinery workshop for 13 years · 7 minute read · Published · Last updated

The problem in one line

Retention held before VAT still owes its VAT at release; retention held after VAT has already had its VAT declared, so the release must carry none.

Retention is the money that comes back last. Part of it after handover, the rest after the defects period, and sometimes in pieces nobody planned for. By the time the release invoice is due, the person who raised the claims may have moved on, and the sheet that tracked the retention is several versions old.

That release invoice has one question on it that decides whether your VAT is right: does it carry VAT? The answer was settled on the claims. You just have to know how they were done.

Two ways to hold it back

Every claim follows one method for all of its deductions, and retention is one of them.

  • Deductions before VAT: the retention comes off the work before VAT is worked out. The claim charges no VAT on it, so what you are holding back is a net amount.
  • Deductions after VAT: VAT is worked out on the whole claim first, then the retention comes off with its VAT. The claim declares the retention's VAT, so what you are holding back already includes it.
Retention held on the 1,000,000 contract
10% retention · work billed 30% / 40% / 30%
ClaimHeld, before VATHeld, after VAT
Claim 130,000.0031,500.00
Claim 240,000.0042,000.00
Claim 330,000.0031,500.00
Held at handover100,000.00105,000.00

After VAT each figure includes 5%: the 1,500, 2,000 and 1,500 of VAT inside them were declared on those claims.

Mizarah contract panel on a phone: QTN-2026-0001, AED 100,000, 30% billed so far, billed to date 30,000, left to bill 70,000, advance recovered 9,000, retention held 3,000.
A 100,000 contract after its first 30% claim: 3,000.00 of retention held, taken off before VAT. Local test data, invented names.

Before VAT: the release is where the VAT is declared

The retention was held without VAT, so its VAT has never been declared anywhere. The release is a tax invoice for the retention plus 5%: 100,000 + 5,000 = 105,000. Its tax point is the release date, so its VAT goes in the return for the period you release it, whenever that is.

Retention release tax invoice
deductions before VAT
TAX INVOICE
LineAmount
Retention released100,000.00
VAT (5%)5,000.00
Total (AED)105,000.00

It is a tax invoice like any other: numbered in your normal invoice sequence, with your TRN, your client's TRN if they have one, and the date. The only unusual thing about it is that the work it taxes was finished long ago.

Raise this release without VAT and 5% of the retention is never declared at all. This is the "not at all" half of the problem, and the easier half to miss, because a release with no VAT looks tidy on paper.

After VAT: the release carries none

Here the retention's VAT was declared on each claim as it went: 1,500 on claim 1, 2,000 on claim 2 and 1,500 on claim 3. The release asks for the 105,000 that was held back, VAT included, and declares nothing. Put VAT on it again and the same 5,000 is declared twice.

Deductions before VAT5,000.00
  1. On the three claims0.00
  2. On the release tax invoice5,000.00
Deductions after VAT5,000.00
  1. Claim 11,500.00
  2. Claim 22,000.00
  3. Claim 31,500.00
  4. On the release0.00
Where the 5,000 of VAT on the 100,000 retention is declared. Before VAT: all of it on the release. After VAT: spread over the claims, none on the release.
The release, both ways
the whole 100,000 retention
LineBefore VATAfter VAT
Retention released100,000.00105,000.00
VAT declared on the release5,000.000.00
Payable105,000.00105,000.00

Either way the client pays 105,000 and you declare 5,000 once. The only difference is which period's return carries it.

Your retention account shows the difference too. Before VAT it holds 100,000 at handover, the retention without its VAT. After VAT it holds 105,000, because the VAT is already inside each amount withheld. If the balance on your retention account does not match one of those two pictures, the claims were not all done the same way.

Releasing it in parts, and the fil that does not round away

Retention rarely comes back in one payment. Each part is its own document on its own date. Under before VAT, each part is its own tax invoice, and each tax invoice has to be right on its own face. So its VAT is rounded on that document, to the nearest fils, which is what the FTA's tax invoice guide asks for.

The 100,000 released in three parts
deductions before VAT · VAT rounded per invoice
ReleaseRetentionVAT (5%)
First release33,333.331,666.67
Second release33,333.331,666.67
Third release33,333.341,666.67
Total100,000.005,000.01

5,000.01, not 5,000.00, and that is correct. Each invoice is right on its face, and across a contract the VAT may differ from exactly 5% by rounding fils only. I would not adjust the last invoice to make the total come out round. It would then be wrong on its own.

Under after VAT there is nothing to round on a release, because it carries no VAT. Each part returns its share of the VAT-inclusive amount held.

How to tell, years later, which way a claim was done

Sometimes the release falls to someone who never saw the claims. The method is not always written down, but the claim itself usually gives it away. Take claim 1 of the reference contract, 300,000 of work:

  • Before VAT: the retention line reads 30,000, and the VAT on the claim is 9,000, which is 5% of the 180,000 left after the advance and the retention came off.
  • After VAT: the retention line reads 31,500, 10% of the 315,000 including VAT, and the claim shows VAT on the whole 300,000 of work before anything comes off.
  • Neither: the retention reads 30,000 but the VAT is 10,500. That is the mix, where the advance came off before VAT and the retention stayed inside it. Stop and work out what was declared before you raise anything.

Check two or three claims on the same contract, not just one. If they all point the same way, you know what the release needs.

Keeping track until it comes back

Retention is rarely hard to calculate; what goes wrong is remembering it. A release can fall due long after handover, and the claim sheet that knew how it was held is rarely the file anyone opens. A few habits fix most of it:

  • Keep retention on its own receivable account, contract by contract, not inside the customer's balance.
  • Record which method each contract's claims used. That one fact decides whether the release carries VAT.
  • Release only retention from claims that were actually issued and posted, never from a draft.
  • When the last release is done, the retention account for that contract should read zero.

And chase it the way you chase any other invoice. A release slips easily: by then everyone on the client's side has moved on to the next job, and a WhatsApp message about a project that finished long ago is easy to leave unanswered.

Mizarah Sales page on a phone, the path money takes: Quote, Order, Delivery, Invoice, Payment and Retention, with Retention showing 2 and AED 13,000 held back.
The last step of the path money takes, on Mizarah's Sales page: Retention, here 13,000.00 still held back. Local test data, invented names.
HOW MIZARAH HANDLES ITTRUE OF THE PRODUCT TODAY

How Mizarah handles it.

In Mizarah each claim takes its retention off under your company's method and posts it to the retention account, contract by contract. Release retention records each part on its own date: leave the amount blank to release all that is held, or type the part that arrived. You cannot release more than is still held, and only posted claims count.

For retention held before VAT, the release raises a retention release tax invoice with its VAT on the release date, rounded on that document. Retention held after VAT comes back as cash with no VAT, because its VAT was declared on the claims.

QUESTIONS6 ANSWERS

Common questions.

Is VAT on retention due when the claim is issued or when the retention is released?
It depends on the claims' method. Deductions before VAT: at the release, on a tax invoice dated the release day. Deductions after VAT: on each claim, and the release carries none. Either way it is declared once.
Can I release retention without VAT if the claims were done before VAT?
No. Those claims never declared the retention's VAT, so the release is where it is declared. A release with no VAT leaves 5% of the retention undeclared.
The main contractor pays the release in two parts. What do I raise?
One release for each part, on the date it arrives. Before VAT, each is its own tax invoice with its VAT rounded to the fils on that invoice.
Why is the VAT on my three release invoices 5,000.01?
Because VAT is rounded on each invoice. Three releases of 33,333.33, 33,333.33 and 33,333.34 carry 1,666.67 each. Across a contract the total may differ from 5% by rounding fils only.
How do I know which method an old contract's claims used?
Look at the claims. Before VAT, the retention is a plain percentage of the work and the VAT is 5% of what was left after the deductions. After VAT, the retention includes its VAT and the VAT is worked out on the whole work first.
Is retention the same as a penalty for VAT?
No. Retention is part of the price, held back and paid later. A penalty or backcharge reduces the contract value, so it reduces the taxable value and carries no VAT later.

Official sources

Read next on this site

Practical guidance, not tax advice. The figures are worked examples, not anyone’s real contract. Check how the rules apply to your own contracts with your tax agent.

TRY IT ON YOUR OWN CONTRACT14 DAYS FREE · NO CARD

Put one of your own claims through it.

Start the free 14-day trial at mizarah.com and bill a contract you already know the answer to. Or work one bill out first with the free progress bill calculator, either VAT method, no sign-up.